Blog
Cashback, Store Credit or Commission: Which One Actually Pays You Back?
Quick answer: in cashback vs store credit, cashback wins on flexibility and store credit wins on size — but store credit only beats it if you were already going to shop there.
Key takeaways
- In cashback vs store credit, cashback is the most flexible — it spends anywhere.
- Store credit is worth more only if you’d already shop there, and it usually expires.
- Commission is the only one of the three that pays from other people’s purchases.
Three offers, three very different promises, and a lot of marketing designed to make them sound equivalent. A 5% cashback card, a store that returns your money as credit, and a programme paying 1% commission are not competing versions of the same thing — they behave differently, and one of them can be worth nothing at all depending on how you shop.
Cashback returns a small percentage of spending as cash or statement credit, usually capped. Store credit returns a larger amount but only spends at one retailer and typically expires. Commission pays you a percentage of other people’s purchases. Cashback is the most flexible; store credit is worth the most if you were already shopping there.
How do the three actually differ?
They differ in what you receive, where you can spend it, and whether it expires. Those three variables determine the real value far more than the headline percentage does:
| Cashback | Store credit | Commission | |
|---|---|---|---|
| You receive | Cash or statement credit | Spendable balance at one store | Cash or wallet balance |
| Typical rate | 0.5–5%, usually capped | Up to 100% of a subscription | 0.25–1% per level |
| Based on | Your own spending | Your own subscription | Other people’s purchases |
| Spendable where | Anywhere | One retailer only | Anywhere |
| Expires? | Rarely | Often — 30 days is common | No |
The two rows doing the most work are “spendable where” and “expires.” A high percentage that expires unused at one shop is worth less than a small percentage in cash — and a small percentage in cash is worth less than a large one you were always going to spend anyway. The right answer depends entirely on your actual shopping behaviour.
When is cashback the better deal?
When your spending is unpredictable or spread across many merchants. Cashback’s advantage is that it never forces a purchase — the money arrives as cash and behaves as cash, so nothing is lost if your habits change next month.
Its weakness is size. UAE cashback cards typically pay between 0.5% and 5%, and the higher rates almost always carry caps, minimum monthly spend requirements, or category restrictions. A card advertising 5% might pay it on the first 500 AED of supermarket spend only, dropping to 0.5% afterwards — meaning the realistic annual return on a household grocery budget is often in the low hundreds of dirhams.
Cashback is the sensible default if you cannot reliably predict where you will spend. It asks nothing of you and penalises nothing.
When is store credit worth more?
When you were already going to spend that amount at that retailer — in which case store credit dramatically outperforms any cashback rate. The arithmetic is not close.
Take a household spending 300 AED a month on groceries, cleaning products and personal care. Under a 2% cashback card, that returns 6 AED a month. Under the MHM Stores membership, you pay 300 AED and receive the full 300 AED back as store credit — spendable on the same essentials, at the same store. If you genuinely spend it, the effective return is not 2%, it is the whole amount.
| Monthly essentials spend | 2% cashback returns | MHM credit received | Credit actually used |
|---|---|---|---|
| 300 AED | 6.00 AED | 300 AED | 300 AED — full value |
| 200 AED | 4.00 AED | 300 AED | 200 AED — 100 AED expires |
| 120 AED | 2.40 AED | 300 AED | 120 AED — 180 AED expires |
Read the bottom row carefully, because it is the honest one. If your household only spends 120 AED a month on essentials, 180 AED of credit expires every month and the membership costs you real money. Store credit at MHM Stores is valid for 30 days and does not roll over. That rule is what makes the top row excellent and the bottom row a bad decision.
Where does commission fit in?
Commission is a different category altogether: it pays you from other people’s purchases rather than your own, which means it stacks on top of either of the others rather than replacing them. It is also, per person, the smallest of the three.
At MHM Stores the rate is 1% at Level 1 — 3.00 AED per month from a direct referral’s 300 AED subscription — dropping to 0.5%, 0.25% and 0.25% across the deeper levels. Nobody should choose a shopping arrangement because of that number. It matters only as an addition to a decision you would make anyway on the shopping merits.
What commission does have, uniquely, is independence from your own spending. Cashback and store credit both require you to spend money to receive anything. Commission does not — once a referral is active, it generates a small amount regardless of what you personally buy that month. The full four-level math shows what that compounds to.
Which should you choose?
Work out your genuine monthly spend at the retailer first, then decide — in that order, not the reverse. This single step prevents nearly every bad outcome in this category.
If you reliably spend 300 AED or more a month on everyday essentials, store credit that returns the full amount beats any cashback rate available, because no card returns 100%. If your essentials spending is well below that, or varies wildly month to month, cashback is the safer structure — a smaller return with nothing to lose. If you are close to the line, remember that credit expires and cashback does not, so the uncertainty argues for cashback.
Commission belongs in the calculation last, as upside on a decision already justified by the shopping. Anyone presenting it the other way around — earn first, shop second — has the priorities inverted, which is worth noticing.
Check your own number first. If you spend it anyway, getting all 300 back is hard to beat.
The bottom line: cashback vs store credit vs commission
In the cashback vs store credit question there is no single winner — cashback is the most flexible, store credit is worth the most if you were already shopping there, and commission is the only one that keeps paying from other people’s purchases. If commission interests you, see how a referral commission actually works and when you get paid.
Investopedia’s explainer on cash back covers the fundamentals. Want a reward that refunds your essentials in AED? Join the MHM Stores network.
Frequently asked questions
Is store credit better than cashback?
Only if you reliably spend it. Store credit can return far more — up to the full subscription amount — but it works at one retailer and often expires. Cashback returns less but arrives as flexible cash that never goes to waste.
Does MHM store credit expire?
Yes. Credit is valid for 30 days from issue and does not roll over into the following month. Unused credit is lost, which is why the membership only makes financial sense for households genuinely spending around 300 AED monthly on essentials.
Can I combine cashback and store credit?
Often yes. If you pay the subscription with a cashback card, you may earn cashback on the payment and receive store credit from the membership. Check your card’s terms, as some exclude subscriptions or specific merchant categories.
What is a good cashback rate in the UAE?
Everyday rates typically fall between 0.5% and 3%, with headline rates of 5% or more usually capped by monthly spend limits or restricted to specific categories. Always read the cap — it determines the real return far more than the advertised percentage.
Do I earn commission on my own purchases?
No. Commission at MHM Stores is paid on purchases made by people in your network, not on your own spending. Your own return comes through the store credit, which refunds the full 300 AED subscription for use on essentials.
